I arrived at Target Center at a little past 9:00, but there was already a large number of people in front of the entrance. These were the people who ended up sitting on the lower deck.

I had eight signs, using both sides of four pieces of poster board. I will tell you more about my signs later.
I was interviewed by David Usborne, an American correspondant for The Independent in the UK, who seemed like a reasonably nice man. The fact that I knew Robert Fisk wrote for the Independent, and that I had read The Independent when I was in Edinburgh in 2006 for the WWW Conference, gave me a little bit of credibility with him. He was especially nice to give me the last word in
his report on the rally.
I was also interviewed by a lady for MinnPost, who used to work for the Pioneer-Press. She was the one who told me that the lady I was speaking with a few minutes ago was Coleen Rowley, who has gone from being Time's Person of the Year in 2002, to running a fumbling campaign against Rep. John Kline, to being the Twin Cities version of Cindy Sheehan, someone who is no longer useful to the Left.

There were protesters to the left and right of Obamacare at the event. There were a number of people demanding a single-payer healthcare system, and people like me, who had all sorts of interesting signs.

I really liked the one that said "Keep bickering, it's gone down from 47 million to 30 million."
There were quite a few members of a number of different unions (machinists, postal workers, nurses) attending the event, but I never saw a larger group than seven people being together wearing union shirts. I didn't see one SEIU garment. The Teamsters parked a semi across the street from Target Center, but kept to themselves. They had coffee and donuts, but I'm not exactly sure who they were for. I had a brief, civil conversation with a Teamster leader about
the Teamster's plans for the kneecapping unionization of FedEx.

I experienced one walk-by heckler, but the people attending the event were generally civil.
One bad thing about the protesters is that they mostly stayed in one spot, across the street from the main entrance of Target Center.


The line snaked back and forth for a long way in a generally northeast direction up Hennepin Avenue. I decided that I would walk from the front of the line to the back of the line, and I did this multiple times. On further review, I wish that the other protestors had done this as well. Most of my signs were seen relatively up close by thousands of people. Here were my signs that I showed the most...
"2 + 2 = 4" In smaller letters, I wrote, "Price controls fail," "Markets R Virtuous" and "Gov't Is The Problem" with "No Matter What Obama Says" in little tiny letters at the bottom. If anyone picked up the 1984 reference, nobody decided to engage me about it. I think some people saw that sign and decided I was slightly insane.
"O-Care ++Ungood" with "Big Brother Is Watching You" in smaller letters, and "Freedom Is Slavery" in little tiny letters. This was on the back side of the "2 + 2 = 4" sign. Again, no takers on the 1984 reference.
"How Many Trillions?" with "9 Too Many, At Least" in little tiny letters. This sign got quite a bit of comment. Lots of people said something like "How many trillions have we spent in Iraq?" or "Bush doubled the national debt." This is what I learned that may or may not be important.
IF YOU WANT TO ANNOY AN OBAMA SUPPORTER, JUST POINT OUT WAYS THAT OBAMA IS LIKE BUSH.
One could say things such as, "Bush got us into Iraq, Obama is keeping us in Iraq. Bush got us into Afghanistan, and Obama is keeping us in Afghanistan. Bush locked up the terrorists in Gitmo, and Obama is keeping them in Gitmo. Bush suggested FISA wiretapping, and Obama voted for it. Bush bailed out Wall Street, Obama stole GM and Chrysler for the unions. There must be 50 similar things that one could say. But they would all be excellent ways of poking holes in the beliefs that Obama supporters have that President Obama is nobler, more honest, more decent, more humane and more magnanimous than former President Bush.
I grasped that passing Obamacare was the Operation Iraqi Freedom for these people, what they grasped as their chance to do something they thought was good, what they grasped as their chance to make an impact. While it's hardly original, I grasp that's a deep hunger in people, one that politicians love to exploit.
"Hands Off Our $" - I had graphic issues with this sign, and so didn't show it very much, as the "How Many Trillions?" sign was working so well.
"Fix Medicare First" - There were quite a few people with some kind of sticker or sign or button that said "Medicare for Everybody" People who are getting Medicare are happy with their health care, but they're not going to be happy when Medicare goes bankrupt in the not-too-distant future. I was very disappointed with the lack on comment on this sign.
I thought this person's sign was unspeakably hilarious, and so I consider it entirely good and right that this young man (Dan Hillenbrand, student at the University of St. Thomas) was quoted in the Star-Tribune coverage of the rally.

Another thing about observing the line is that there were quite a few people with clipboards up and down the line, signing people up to do this, that or the other. I'm not sure how many of them were with formal Obama organizations, and how many were merely organizational allies, but I'm unhappy that they were taking names of people who would eventually do something, and I wasn't. Another one of the protesters in front of Target Center commented, "If we can only get a hundred people to show up when Obama comes to town on a Saturday morning with gorgeous weather, it's plain to see we're not very organized." I don't have a snappy comeback for that observation. I was hoping to see some of my colleagues in the Minnesota Organization of Blogs, but I didn't. None of the protesters actually went in to the event, which was a great pity, as a lusty chorus of boos and heckling might have been very helpful indeed.
They decided to fill one section of the upper deck at a time, so once one got into Target Center, it was still very crowded. It's a good thing people were very polite.

Channel 5 showed President Obama stepping off Air Force One on the big screens at Target Center at about 12:15. All the people who might have been at Target Center as preliminary speakers, were meeting the President at the airport.
2012 Vice-President Senator Amy Klobuchar and Senator Al Franken were there, along with other important people.
A lady minister gave a rambling invocation. There was the reciting of the Pledge of Allegiance, and the singing of the national anthem. HHS Secretary Sibelius came on and gave a perfunctory recitation of the talking points. There was starting to be a lull about 1:00 when President Obama arrived.

Should I consider the fact that President Obama is going back to the thing he knows best, campaigning, as an admission that his other strategies were not succeeding? That would be a nice way of thinking about it. President Obama entered like a prize fighter, with his jacket off, his sleeves rolled up, shaking hands with as many people as possible in the VIP section before going on stage.

I don't really understand why the podium was turned toward one of the corners of Target Center, but it was.
There were the usual remarks of praise for local Democrats, with the notable exception of Rep. Keith Ellison. So maybe President Obama has other issues with Keith Ellison, maybe Obama's snub of Ellison during the campaign wasn't just business. Who knows?
There wasn't really anything novel about Obama's speech. You can
see the video and read the transcript here. Here's my summary: "People experience misfortune, people shouldn't experience misfortune, government is the solution to people experiencing misfortune. I will sign a law that says people shouldn't experience misfortune. Everyone who disagrees with me is an advocate of the status quo, a liar, a con, a manipulator, a stooge of special interests. I want all my supporters to
get in my opponents' faces with brass fisties, and bootsy-woots if thou it suits."
I was scared when I saw this person's button...

.
I take consolation in that the more President Obama talks, the less people like him and his ideas. I take further consolation in the fact that President Obama seems to think that talking to America more, and getting more swaggering and Chicagoish is the solution to his problems. At the rate we're going, America is going to kill Obamacare just to avoid having to listen to a historic speech-to-end-all-speeches on health care every week.
Labels: Barack Obama